rating: 3 of 5 stars
I think Chuck Klosterman has become slyly brilliant as he progressed as a writer since this, honing his "It's one thing, but really it's something else entirely" shtick into an occasional scalpel, but the references and concerns here seem so dated that it feels like reading old issues of Spin, which is, I guess, what this is.
He is a guy that gets thrown under the bus a lot because he is cast in a position of authority by expressing his Everyman-ity at every turn. Like every other snob, I don't think he has very enlightened tastes in music, but he has a way of making really brilliant things out of his observations. Like this:
The Hold Steady Almost Killed Me (2004):
You will like this album if you used to like AC/DC but now you just read a lot.
or his notion expressed in a reprinted article collected in Chuck Klosterman IV that the first Van Halen album is the most average record of all time, and if you like a record more than it, its a good record; less, and its a bad record.
Things like this seem to be tossed out for a laugh and they are, but there is something penetrating here, something that digs a little deeper than you thought there was ground under the subjects he peruses.
View all my reviews.